The “deplorables”
despise the Democrats.
A central cause
of Sec. Clinton’s shocking defeat to Donald Trump, Clinton’s history of touting
neoliberal economic policy precluded her from making inroads in the white
working class (WWC). If the Democrats wish to win back the presidency from
Trump and the GOP, they must abandon their stale centrism and elect Rep. Keith
Ellison—a true progressive—as DNC chairman. By electing Keith Ellison as
chairman of the DNC, the Democratic Party can build a coalition of black,
Latino and white workers that will help elect Democrats at all levels of
government.
Suspicious of
Clinton’s rapport with Wall Street, members of the WWC, many of whom voted for
Barack Obama in 2012, voted for Trump’s ethno-nationalist program. In the
Democratic strongholds of Wisconsin, Michigan and Pennsylvania, white laborers
rejected Clinton’s moderate economic plan, opting for Trump’s criticism of the “elite”
class and his contempt for free trade.
In order to
wrest power from the hands of Trump and the GOP, it is imperative that the
Democrats steal some of the WWC vote. Only by acknowledging their long-held
grievances will the Democratic party be able to appeal to this demographic and
take back the Rust Belt.
While many of
these WWC voters may be racist philistines, there is assuredly a significant
portion of them who could have been swayed not to vote for Trump. Indeed, just because
some downscale whites voted for Trump, it does not automatically qualify half
of them as “irredeemable.” Instead of haranguing the WWC, the Democratic party
needed to convince them to join a Leftist platform that addressed their
economic anxiety. It behooves the party to pivot towards a progressivism that does
not simply call struggling whites racist but tries to bring them into a broad,
inclusive coalition.
Phone banking laborers
in Ohio for Sanders’ presidential campaign, I know first-hand how much a
message of economic security for all
people (black, Latino, Asian, white) can resonate with the WWC.
As polls during
the primary hinted at, a Sanders-style is the most effective way to combat the
racist populism of Donald Trump. With a progressive economic message, Senator
Bernie Sanders started a dialogue with struggling whites that made him
incredibly popular within the WWC. This popularity was borne out by the variety
of head-to-head polls showing Sanders doing much better than Clinton in a
general election with Trump.
The Democrats
need to embrace Sanders and his political vision, starting with a change in
party leadership.
That is why the
Democratic party should make Rep. Keith Ellison the chairman of the DNC. A
black Muslim and a true fighter for racial and economic justice, Ellison, a
Sanders surrogate during the primaries, is the perfect person to shape the new
Democratic vision. It is so vital that Ellison becomes head of the DNC because,
in that capacity, he would be able to dictate Democratic policy, purge special
interests from the party and allocate funds to important grassroots
organizations.
Furthermore,
Ellison repudiates the notion that the Democrats cannot appeal to the WWC without
compromising their commitment to racial and gender equality. As a Minnesota
representative, Keith Ellison, like Bernie Sanders, showed America that politicians
are not compelled to use racist appeals when trying to capture the WWC vote.
In short, Ellison’s
staunch support for economic and racial equity, along with his sympathy for the
WWC, makes him the ideal politician to lead the party’s transition from being a
party of elites to a tribune of everyday Americans.
The Democrats
cannot afford to choose another establishment stalwart, like Debbie Wasserman
Schultz, who sabotaged Sanders’ campaign, or Donna Brazile, to steer the metaphorical
ship. The party must shake things up and elect Keith Ellison, a progressive
caucus member who can change the core philosophy of the Democratic Party and help
them win the WWC vote.
Whatever upsides
there are to Howard Dean being the DNC chairman, they are outweighed by his
commitment to the current Democratic leadership. Despite his progressive
persona during the 04’ primaries, Dean, a big pharma lobbyist, exists as an
establishment figure who will only perpetuate the status quo and alienate
struggling whites. If party officials elect Dean, it would send a strong signal
that Democrats have failed to learn the lessons of this election.
Instead of a
party that pays lip-service to “diversity” while, at the same time, providing
favorable economic conditions to economic elites on Wall Street and in Silicon
Valley, the Democrats should be a group that fights for all of the working class—black, Latino and white.
The Democrats
must respond to the allure of Trump’s ethno-nationalism with a progressive, not
a centrist, platform. With Keith Ellison spearheading a leftist movement, the
Democrats will stem the tide of neo-fascism and bring the WWC into the party
with a message of egalitarianism.
I really like Keith Ellison and I'm hoping that he gets the chairmanship. What a disaster the DNC was for their most necessary election in history and they blew it. Debbie Wasserman-Schultz was awful, played to elites, favored Hillary, and pushed Bernie out. That ultimately led to the loss of not only the presidency but probably congress too. The DNC was rocked by scandal and hopefully they can get it together before midterms and also have a strong candidate ready to take the white house back in four years. This was not the year to be messing up, but hopefully they learned their lesson. Playing to the elites gets funding but not votes.
ReplyDeleteI think there are some gambles to Ellison's nomination, not that he isn't fit for office, but that he is farther left and more parochial in some aspects of his interests. Not even Nostradomus could spell out what 2020 will look like, but there is a potential repeat of the 2016 election if the Democratic party cannot complete the rebranding process by then. THAT SAID, I believe it's a necessary part of the process. If the democratic party can call itself a progressive part one it needs the voice of a progressive (Ellison, check) and a solid voter base devoted to the platform. That may take more time, and I think even with a failed 2020 election, the democratic party is best of reformulating its outlook.
ReplyDeleteI think that it is great that Keith Ellison has such wide support from many in the party. I will gladly support him. However, I think you may be a little quick to dismiss someone like Howard Dean. Keith Ellison is a better and more interesting choice, but Dean is well known for his amazing internet campaign and grassroots fundraising in 2004. Those are skills that are important for DNC chairman. However, I agree that it is paramount that we rebrand and rebuild as soon as possible, and that will be harder to do with someone like Howard Dean as DNC chairman.
ReplyDeleteI'm going to play devil's advocate for a bit. Based on what I've read, Keith Ellison seems to be a pretty decent pick for DNC chair; it seems that under him, Dems would be able to get party realignment in the sense that left-leaners will vote for Dems rather than voting third party or even switching teams. I'm more interested in how Ellison would be able to convince true moderates and moderate right-leaners to support the party with him as a black Muslim. Race and religion, ideally, shouldn't be part of a judgement of an effective political leader. But I've gotten a little cynical these days. We're entering Trump's America, in which a large portion of people hold a sort of racism, dislike of certain aspects of progressive liberalism and fear against Muslims that we were all technically aware of, but we just didn't know how deep it went until the election. I'm admittedly not too well-versed in the politics the Democratic Party, but biases and fear go a really long way. Ellison would need to be a really strong leader to guide the party's re-branding in light of that.
ReplyDelete